当前在线人数8682
首页 - 分类讨论区 - 学术学科 - 生物学版 - 同主题阅读文章

此篇文章共收到打赏
0

  • 10
  • 20
  • 50
  • 100
您目前伪币余额:0
未名交友
[更多]
[更多]
Re: 刚发现一篇有问题的NATURE文章
[版面:生物学][首篇作者:AXD9805] , 2011年04月22日21:10:43 ,次阅读,次回复
来APP回复,赚取更多伪币 关注本站公众号:
[分页:1 ]
AXD9805
进入未名形象秀
我的博客
[回复] [回信给作者] [本篇全文] [本讨论区] [修改] [删除] [转寄] [转贴] [收藏] [举报] [ 1 ]

发信人: AXD9805 (mayflower), 信区: Biology
标  题: Re: 刚发现一篇有问题的NATURE文章
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Fri Apr 22 21:10:43 2011, 美东)

From:XXX
Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 5:39 PM
To: '[email protected]'
Subject: potential fabrication shown up in recent Nature paper

Dear Editor,

The fabricated paper is “Aycan Sentürk, Sylvia Pfennig, Alexander Weiss,
Katja Burk & Amparo Acker-Palmer. Ephrin Bs are essential components of the
Reelin pathway to regulate neuronal migration. Nature. Volume 472, Pages:
356–360 Date published: (21 April 2011) DOI: doi:10.1038/nature09874”

The evidence for the fabrication:

The Figure 1a: the 2nd and 3rd panels are labeled with different genotypes,
suggesting from different mice. However, the patterns between 2nd and 3rd
panels are exactly the same, suggesting they are actually from the same
section and likely the same image.

More data found in this paper are likely to be fabricated including: Fig.1c,
2nd vs. 3rd panels; Fig.S4, 1st vs. 2nd panels and Fig.S5 c4 vs. e4.

The original person found the fabrication is unknown. He/she reported this
finding in MITBBS biological forum (in Chinese) which now is a very hot
topic. Please see here: http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t1/Biology/31507303_0_1.html

It is my responsibility to make a report if I see it. So please check the
original paper to see if the reported fabrication exists or not.
Sincerely




----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----

From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 5:39 PM
To: XXX
Subject: Out of Office AutoReply: potential fabrication shown up in recent
Nature paper

Thank you for your email. Due to the Easter Holidays these emails will not
be checked until Tuesday 26th April. We will endeavor to get back to you as
soon as possible!






【 在 GOPLAYGO (大道无门) 的大作中提到: 】
: 起来趁脑袋清醒地时候读文章,顺便看看这一期的Nature吧。
: 上去打开一篇,还没看内容呢就发现Fig1里面就有几张图好像有些问题。
: 有点不相信自己的眼睛,这打开一篇就有问题,还是NATURE上的,比中大奖的几率也大
: 不了多少吧。
: 大家看看吧,Fig1A,1C。第二,三张图。
: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v472/n7343/full/nature09874.html
: 照理说,那些审稿人和编辑们都目光如电的,真是有点难以置信。
: 还好作者中没有国人



--

※ 来源:·WWW 未名空间站 海外: mitbbs.com 中国: mitbbs.cn·[FROM: 71.165.]

 
[分页:1 ]
[快速返回] [ 进入生物学讨论区] [返回顶部]
回复文章
标题:
内 容:

未名交友
将您的链接放在这儿

友情链接


 

Site Map - Contact Us - Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy

版权所有,未名空间(mitbbs.com),since 1996